Your Mortgage Pre-Approved in 24 Hours or Less. Apply Now!

FHSA vs. RRSP Home Buyers’ Plan: Which One Should You Actually Use?

You can use both tools for the same home. The first home savings account (FHSA) and the home buyers plan (HBP) can work together, so you do not have to choose just one. Together, a buyer can use up to $100,000 for one down payment.

Picture this. You sit at the kitchen table with two account statements open. One is an FHSA. The other is a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) that has grown for years. Your down payment target is still a blur, and you are not sure which account to use first.

This guide gives home buyers three clear decisions. You will know how much each account lets you use, how the tax works, and how repayment differs. Contribution room is the maximum amount you are allowed to put into an account in a given year, and it builds up if you do not use it.

Before you read on, check which of the two accounts you have already opened. The FHSA clock starts on the day you open it, so that date matters more than you may think.

Key Takeaways

  • The FHSA and the HBP can both fund the same first home.
  • Together, you can use up to $100,000 for one down payment.
  • The FHSA allows $8,000 a year, up to $40,000 in total, with no repayment.
  • The HBP lets you withdraw up to $60,000 per person from your RRSP.
  • HBP withdrawals must be repaid over 15 years.
  • Unused contribution room builds up for future years.

What the FHSA Gives You Each Year

You can put up to $8,000 into an FHSA each year, and up to $40,000 in total. Those two limits set the pace of your saving. Your FHSA is a savings account, so the money you put in can be invested inside it.

The annual limit is $8,000, and the lifetime limit is $40,000. You do not have to reach the lifetime cap in one step. Plan your saving over several years, and use each year’s room as it opens up.

Annual and lifetime contribution limits

The FHSA sets a yearly cap and a total cap. Four rules shape how much room you have in any year.

  • The annual contribution limit is $8,000.
  • The lifetime contribution limit is $40,000.
  • Unused room carries forward by up to $8,000 a year.
  • Your room starts on the date you open your first FHSA.

Those rules give you a clear ceiling for each year. Check the yearly cap before you decide how much to move into the account.

Carrying forward unused room

Unused room does not disappear. Say you put $5,000 into your FHSA in year one. You leave $3,000 of your room unused, and that $3,000 carries forward.

In year two, your room is $11,000. That is the new $8,000 plus the $3,000 carried forward from year one. The most you can put in during one year is $16,000, which happens when a full $8,000 carries forward.

Open the account early, because every year you wait without an account is a year of room you cannot use.

How FHSA Tax Savings Work

A contribution to your FHSA lowers your taxable income, and a qualifying withdrawal is not taxed. That gives you two tax benefits in one account. The first comes when you put money in, and the second comes when you take it out for a home.

FHSA contributions are generally tax-deductible, and a qualifying withdrawal to buy or build a home is tax-free. A deduction lowers the income you pay tax on. Say you earn $60,000 and put $8,000 into your FHSA. Your taxable income drops to $52,000, which lowers the tax you owe that year.

A withdrawal counts as qualifying only when three things are true. The purchase must be your first home in Canada. The withdrawal must follow the FHSA withdrawal rules. A withdrawal that does not qualify is taxable, so it adds to your income for that year.

The tax break on the way in is worth the most when your income is high. A deduction only helps if you have taxable income to reduce. Growth inside the account is also sheltered from tax while the money stays there.

Keep your withdrawal request paperwork, since the qualifying withdrawal must be documented.

The Home Buyers’ Plan Withdrawal Limit and Timing

You can withdraw up to $60,000 per person from your RRSP under the home buyers plan (HBP). The money must go toward a qualifying home. Under the HBP, you can withdraw 60,000 Canadian dollars from your RRSP, and your partner can do the same.

The limit rose from $35,000 to $60,000 per person on April 16, 2024. HBP withdrawals are not taxed at the time you take them when the conditions are met. A couple can each withdraw $60,000, so two buyers can take $120,000 in total.

Who qualifies and what the home must be

Four conditions must be met before you can use the HBP. Check each one before you apply.

  • You must be a resident of Canada.
  • You must be a first-time buyer of a home.
  • You must sign a written agreement to buy or build the home.
  • You must intend to live in the home within one year of buying or building it.

The qualifying home must be a housing unit in Canada. That includes a house, townhouse, mobile home, condominium or apartment.

The withdrawal window

You can make the withdrawal up to 30 days after the closing date. Closing is the day the home becomes yours on paper and the sale is final. Plan the timing so your withdrawal and your closing date line up.

The HBP depends on your written agreement, so an unsigned purchase agreement can stop the withdrawal.

Repaying an HBP Withdrawal

Each year, you must repay one-fifteenth of what you withdrew, at least. That yearly amount is the minimum. The full repayment takes 15 years.

The annual minimum repayment is 1/15 of your withdrawal. Repayments generally begin in the second year after you withdraw. You pay the money back into your RRSP, not to the lender.

The 1/15 annual repayment

The annual minimum repayment is called the 1/15 repayment. Take a $60,000 withdrawal. Your minimum yearly repayment is $4,000, every year for 15 years.

You can repay more than the minimum. You do this by designating RRSP contributions as HBP repayments. Use these three checks each year.

  • Track your repayment schedule against the 15-year plan.
  • Designate extra RRSP contributions as HBP repayments when you make them.
  • Check whether any shortfall appears in your taxable income for that year.

What happens if you miss a payment

If your repayment falls short, the missing amount is included in your taxable income for that year. You pay tax on it at your normal rate. A missed year can cost you tax you did not plan for.

Set a yearly reminder for each repayment date, so the schedule never slips.

FHSA Deadlines You Cannot Miss

The home must be bought or built by October 1 of the year after your withdrawal. That is the main deadline for using an FHSA. Miss it, and the withdrawal will not qualify as tax-free.

An FHSA must be closed after 15 years or when you turn 71, whichever comes first. Your room starts from the day you open the account, so the clock runs from that date too.

Four deadlines and tests matter most for a buyer.

  • Buy or build the home by October 1 of the year after the withdrawal.
  • Close the account after 15 years, or when you turn 71, whichever comes first.
  • Have not lived in a home you owned as your principal residence in the current year or the previous four calendar years.
  • Make sure the qualifying home is in Canada.

Say you open an FHSA in 2026 and buy your home in 2027. The purchase falls inside the window, so you have time to plan the closing and the paperwork. Mark the 15-year closing date on your calendar the day you open the account.

Why the FHSA Carries No Repayment Burden

Money you take from an FHSA for a qualifying home does not have to be repaid. Unlike an HBP withdrawal, an FHSA withdrawal does not cut into your retirement savings.

Picture a buyer who saves in an FHSA for three years, then changes plans and never buys a home. That buyer can move the unused FHSA money to an RRSP or a registered retirement income fund (RRIF) without immediate tax. This works only when there is no excess FHSA amount.

The two tools treat your retirement savings very differently. With the HBP, the money you borrow from your RRSP stops growing there until you repay it. An FHSA withdrawal for a home never touches your RRSP at all.

An RRSP-to-FHSA transfer counts toward your FHSA limits. It does not give you a new tax deduction, so it is not a second way to save tax.

Ask your advisor before any transfer, since the no-tax result depends on the transfer rules.

Using Both Tools for One Home

Yes, you can use both the FHSA and the HBP for the same home. Each tool has its own rules, so you must track them separately. A couple with two FHSAs and two RRSPs can put up to $200,000 toward one home.

A worked down payment example

Take a couple buying a $750,000 home. Each partner has an FHSA and an RRSP. Each uses $60,000 from the HBP and $40,000 from the FHSA, which adds to $200,000 in total.

A 20% down payment on this home would be $150,000. The combined funds from both tools cover that amount and leave a margin, so the couple has more room to work with.

Common mistakes when combining

Most problems come from losing track of two systems at once. Watch for these three mistakes.

  • Letting HBP repayments fall behind while you save for the next goal.
  • Mixing the paperwork for the FHSA and the HBP in one folder.
  • Forgetting the FHSA closing date.

Track each account on its own, since each has its own forms and clock.

Choosing the Right Route for Your Situation

For most buyers with time to save, the FHSA comes first. Time is the deciding factor. An FHSA needs years to build up, while the HBP can give you money from savings you already hold.

The FHSA is the simpler route because it has no repayment. It also gives you a tax deduction on the way in and a tax-free withdrawal on the way out. Most first-time buyers who start early will find it the easiest to manage.

Take a buyer with a large RRSP but only a few years before buying. The HBP suits this person, because it can release up to $60,000 quickly. The trade-off is the repayment over 15 years, so check that the yearly amount fits your budget.

Take a buyer who wants no repayment at all. The FHSA is the better fit, with $8,000 a year of room. A buyer with savings in both accounts can combine the two, which gives the most room for a down payment. If you want to see how these choices play out in real markets, free mortgage webinars cover these topics.

Compare your RRSP balance and your monthly budget before you commit to a repayment plan.

Conclusion

The FHSA is the no-repayment route, and the HBP is the fast route for money already in your RRSP.

The FHSA allows $8,000 a year, up to $40,000 in total, with no repayment. The HBP allows up to $60,000 per person from your RRSP, repaid over 15 years.

Book a review of your accounts this month, before the next deadline runs.

BM Select is a boutique Ontario mortgage brokerage based in Burlington, serving real estate investors, high-net-worth clients, and first-time home buyers across Canada. We combine institutional-grade mortgage expertise with white-glove, advice-forward service — the kind of partnership most brokerages talk about but few actually deliver.

From first homes to multi-property portfolios to our signature Build Up construction and renovation program, we structure mortgages that work as hard as our clients do.

How can we help you? Let’s start with a 30-minute discovery call. Contact us today at 905-569-8326 or email info@bmselect.ca. You’ll walk away with clarity — whether we work together or not.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or mortgage advice. Mortgage rates, terms, and eligibility are subject to lender qualification and may change without notice. Please consult a licensed mortgage professional for advice tailored to your specific circumstances. Better Mortgage Select – A Division of Better Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage in Ontario Canada.

Posts by Category

Want more monthly insights-

Straight to your inbox?